Observational study of biological and dietetic treatments for Autism Spectrum disorders

Barcelona, December de 2007

CONTENT

RESUM................................................................................................................

1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................. 3

2 METHOD............................................................................................... 6

2.1 Sample selection...........................................................................

2.2 Scales used...................................................................................

2.3 Study’s design.............................................................................7

2.4 Facts collected ..............................................................................

2.5 Treatments and dosage .............................................................. 9

3 RESULTS ........................................................................................... 11

3.1 Description of the sample.......................................................... 11

3.1.1 Sample’s distribution according to age and sex ........................ 12

3.1.2 Another associated patologies ......................................................

3.1.3 Family background........................................................................

3.1.4 Personal background ....................................................................

3.2 First urine analysis results. Time 1............................................ 15

3.2.1 Initial sample .................................................................................

3.2.2 Efective sample.............................................................................

3.3 Clinical evolution ...........................................................................

3.3.1 Phase 1..................................................................................... 17

3.3.2 Phase 2..................................................................................... 18

3.3.3 Other concomitant aspects to remark ....................................... 18

3.3.4 Evaluation of the results according to the CARS test................ 19

3.3.5 Evolution of the arabinose values in the urine........................... 20

3.3.6 Evolution os the morphine-like peptides values in the urine...... 21

4 DISCUSION .............................................................................. 22

BIBLIOGRAPHY ................................................................................. 25

AKNOWLEMENTS.................................¡Error! Marcador no definido.

Observational study of biological and dietetic treatments for Autism Spectrum disorders

RELATION BETWEEN TABLES AND GRAFFICS

Tables

Table 1. - Relation of drugs and supplements ........................ 10

Table 2. - Distribution of the initial and effective sample according to age and sex of the subjects ....................... 13

Table 3. - Relation of the associated pathologies to the initial and effective sample ..................................................... 13

Table 4. - Relation of the family backgrounds relevant to the initial and effective sample ...................................... 13

Table 5. - Relation of incidents during the pregnancy ................. 14

Table 6. - Relation of incidents in the birth ...................... 14

Table 7. - Relation of the reactions to vaccines in the initial sample and the effective sample ............................... 15

Table 8. - Relation of behaviour regressions in the initial sample and the effective sample .......................................... 16

Table 9. - Description of the initial sample according to the arabinose, gluteomorphine and caseomorphine results obtained…………………………………………………. .... 17

Table 10. - Description of the effective sample according to the arabinose, gluteomorphine and caseomorphine results obtained…………………………………………………...... 18

Table 11. - Relation of the improvement level of the subjects from the effective sample after the drainage with homeospagyria ………………………………………........ 18

Table 12. - Relation of the improvement level of the subjects from de effective sample after the second phase ……............... 19

Table 13. - Evolution of the CARS punctuation in the effective sample in T1 and T2....................................................... 20

Graphics

Graphic 1. - Relation of incidents in the birth of the initial sample ………………………………………………........... 15

Graphic 2. - Description of the initial sample according to the arabinose, gluteomorphine and caseomorphine results obtained…………………………………………………..... 16

Observational study of biological and dietetic treatments for Autism Spectrum disorders Observational study of biological and dietetic treatments for Autism Spectrum disorders

Graphic 3. - Description of the effective sample according to the arabinose, gluteomorphine and caseomorphine results obtained…………………………………………………..... 17
Graphic 4. - Valuation according to the CARS in T1 and T2 of the effective sample……...................................................... 20
Graphic 5. - Arabinose’s values in T1 and T2 of the effective sample............................................................................ 21
Graphic 6. - Relation of the global improvement in the treatment according to valuations of CARS, in T1 and T2….......... 23

SUMMARY

Background

In 1942 Leo Kenner described for the first time the autism and in 1943 Hans Asperger defined the diagram that has his same name. From Lorna Wing’s contributions, in 1992, the term Disorders of the Autism Spectrum that, in a more extended way, includes the two former, is incorporated. It is characterized for disturbances in the social interaction and in the communication and to have patterns restricted of behaviours, of interests and of activities.

Aim

The aim of this study is to evaluate the efficiency of a biological and dietetic treatment to attenuate the autism’s symptoms.

Framework Reference

This treatment it’s been defined by three basic props:

The theory formulated by Shattock and Reichelt of peptide opioid excess. According to this, these peptides that result from the gluten and casein incomplete digestion, produce alterations in the neurotransmitters of the brain.

The theory of the yeast colonization in the intestine, by Dr. Shaw, that it entails, of a side a high production of neurotoxins and of the other one an increase of the intestinal permeability with the consequent intestinal dysfunction.

The theory formulated by Dr. Waring of the sulphurous components insufficient elimination by a deficiency of the phenylsulfurtransferase enzyme.

Methods

20 autism patients were enrolled in the study. The patients that have completed the study are 13, which 10 of them are males and 3 females, all of them from 3 to 13 years old. Seven patients abandoned; 4 of them after the first visit for personal motives, 2 of them abandoned because the symptoms aggravated during the drainage and the last 1 also for aggravation of the symptoms with the introduction of the supplements.

Inclusion criteria: boys and girls from 3 to 15 years old, diagnosed with Disorders of the Autism Spectrum. In all the cases the diagnostic was confirmed by the questionnaire corresponding to DSM IV.

Exclusion criteria: patients that had already been in a diet free of gluten and/or casein or that had been in a treatment against the Candidas in the last 6 moths.

The study was programmed to six months and six visits were done. In the first visit, the DSM IV questionnaire and the CARS test were performed, it was requested the urine analysis to determinate the concentration of opioid peptides and organic acids, and we prescribed drainage with homeospagyria and supplement of DHA. In the second visit, according to the results of each individual urine analysis, we prescribed diet without gluten and/or without lactic and/or anti-Candida treatment. In the 3rd, 4th and 5th visits the other supplements and homeopathic and homeospagyria medicines were gradually introduced (see Table 2.5). In the 6th visit we repeated the urine analysis and the CARS tests. In each visit, it was annotated the changes observed in the behaviour and in the attitude, and also the modifications of physical symptoms.

Results

All the 13 individuals that finished the study obtained lower punctuations in the CARS test after the treatment (Time 2) that the ones obtained before starting the treatment (Time 1). The decrease in the CARS punctuations were the following:

The patient that had the best improvement, went from a punctuation of 45 in Time 1 to a punctuation of 29, 5 in Time 2 and went from severe autism to the below limit of the category that suggests borderline autism.

Conclusions

The improvement in the autism’s symptoms after six moths of treatment that the group of the study it has been globally experimenting, suggest that body detoxification diets, treatments of intestinal yeast and/or bacteria, correction of the metabolic errors using the diet and dietetic supplements, allows treat and improve autism symptoms. Then, it could be, very suitable to go deeply into the possibilities that these therapies offer to treat the autism.

Key words

Autism, Asperger, biological and dietetic treatment, opioid peptides, intestinal Candidas, arabinose.

1 INTRODUCTION

In 1943 Leo Kanner, in the U.S., identified and described for the first time, the autism. Right after, in 1944, Hans Asperger, in Austria, described the diagram that has his same name. Some years after, from Lorna Wing’s contributions (1992), it’s incorporated the term Disturbance of the Austim Spectrum that in a more extended way includes the two told before and reflects the large variability that exists in the expression of this disorder.

In the last years the number of cases diagnosticated has considerably increased and, maybe because the diagnostic’s criteria has been enlarged and it could have been an influence, some authors admit that there is a continuous increase in the real number of cases. The autism it’s present in 4 men every 1 women. Nowadays it’s calculated that one every 170 born boys, suffers Disturbance of the Austim Spectrum (1).

Its characteristics are:

  • Qualitative disturbance in the social interaction.
  • Qualitative disturbance in communicating.
  • Restrained standards in behaviour, interests and activities showing in many cases body stereotyped movements.

At present, even though the suspicion can appear sometimes at the age of 12 moths old, in the majority of cases the true diagnostic is done between the age of 30 and 36 moths old.

Framework reference

It is accepted that there are many factors that take part in the ethologic of this disorder, always over the base of a genetic component that, even though nowadays it’s hasn’t been possible to determine, it is thought that different chromosomes are involved. One of these factors could be a metabolic and intestinal dysfunction. Shattock (England, Sunderland University) and Reichelt (Norway) have formulated the hypothesis that the gluten’s peptides and the caseine exercise an ethological function in the pathogenic of the autism disorder. It is suggested that the psychological and behaviour alterations of the autism can be explained by the opioid activity peptides mentioned before, therefore these peptides pay attention to the opioids receptors of the brain, it affects the neurotransmission and provoke modifications on the behaviour. Excessive high levels of these opioids peptides have been measured excreted in the urine of the people with autism –Reichelt (1986) and Shattock (1990)–. Shattock and Whiteley have developed in the past years this theory (2). An enzymatic endopeptidases deficit, especially of Dipeptidil-peptidase IV (DPPIV), and it’s corresponding cofactors (vitamins and minerals), would explain why the digestion of some food (in this case the casein and gluten) could have been incomplete and would cause this abnormal high quantity of peptides in the digestive tract. These peptides, after being absorbed in the intestine, would pass the blood flow: part of it would be excreted by the kidneys and another part would cross the blood-brain barrier and arrive to the brain. Once there would become biologically active in the union with the opioids receptors and would produce interferences in the transition of the cerebral information.

An increase with the permeability intestinal would determine the anomalous absorption of an important quantity of these peptides, that because of its bigness, in physiological conditions of preserving the integrity in the intestinal wall, they wouldn’t have to be absorbed by the intestine. Wakefield and cols. (1998, 2000) studied a sample of 12 kids in a first work (3) and 60 kids in a second work (4), all of them diagnosticated with Disorder of the Autism Spectrum and determined by endoscope, that the 93% shower Hyperplasia Nodular Lymphoid. They concluded that this pathology could be considered as a subtle variation of the inflammatory sickness in the intestine. This intestinal alteration would explain by one side the anomalous absorption of the long-chain peptides and by other side the diminution of the vitamins and minerals absorption.

Dr.Shaw, director of the Great Plains Laboratory of Lenexa (USA), have founded very high levels of arabinose in the urine of many autism children. It suggests that this sugar would be a sub product of the Candides and those high levels in the urine would mean the existence of an intestinal Candida. This excessive growth of the yeast in the intestine would mean other interferences of the neurotransmission and it would contribute to worse the increase of the intestinal impermeabilization. It reports important improvements in the behaviours of children with autism, after doing an antifungal treatment. (5)

An expert group of the USA and Denmark have published in The Lancet magazine, a study where they report that a silence pandemic of the disorders in the neurological development exists caused by chemical toxic products sent to the environment. They have identified 202 industrial chemical products potentially harmful to the human brain that could cause, among others, autism, attention deficit, mental delay and brain paralysis. (6)

Dr. Waring described in 1993 that 90% of autism children had the enzymatic hepatic phenilsulfur-transferase levels decreased (7). This condition would determine a bigger difficult in removing out of the organism the sulphuric components by the hepatic metabolism.

According to this, and always from a special genetic configuration that hasn’t been determined yet and which it is believed that a variety of genes that interact with each other have an intervention in it, we could consider three factors present in the etiopathogeny of the autism:

  • An enzymatic deficit that could cause a metabolic disorder
  • An intestinal inflation accompanied by an increase of the intestinal permeability and dysfunction in the absorption of the nutrients.
  • An accumulation of the toxins in the organism because of a malfunction in the elimination lines.

So, the people that have disorders of the Autism Spectrum would have to benefit from a treatment that would influence in these three aspects.

Objective

The objective of this study is to evaluate the efficiency of a biological and dietetic treatment, previously defined, to attenuate the autism’s symptoms, in a sample of this collective. And the purpose is double:

  • On one side, give the families a treatment that can benefit their children and improve their quality of life.
  • On the other side, stimulate the sanitary institutions in our country and go deeply on researching about the autism treatment, following this therapeutic orientation.

2 METHOD

2.1 Sample’s selection

In order to select the subjects of the sample, the following inclusion and exclusion criteria were defined:

Inclusion criteria: boys and girls from 3 to 15 years old, diagnosticated as Disorder of the Autism Spectrum. In all cases, we confirmed the diagnostic using the questionnaire corresponding to the DSM IV.

Exclusion criteria: patients that had been already following free gluten and/or casein diet, or that had done a treatment against the Candidas in the past 6 moths.

To get in touch with the families we asked for the collaboration of schools with special education in Barcelona and nearness, and also an association of parents with autism’s children and a centre of after school therapies.

2.2 Range used

We used two ranges:

  • DSM IV – R (Diagnostic manual and statistic of the mental disorders); American Psychiatric Association.
  • CARS (The Childhood Autism Rating Scale) of Eric Schopler, Ph.D., Robert J. Reichler, M.D., and Barbara Rochen Renner, Ph.D. It is a judgement range of the childhood autism that has 15 items that help to identify the children with autism and differencing them from other children with development problems that are not autism. It is based on comparing more than 1500 children and its corresponding clinical valuations. The maximum score that it is obtained adding the scores of 15 items is 60 points. Scoring more than 30 points it’s considerate autism. We’ve used this range because it permits an accurate evaluation and it needs the subject’s evolution and the changes that have experimented during the entire treatment. We used the same translation to Spanish that the Unit of Neuropediatric of the Sabadell’s Hospital uses that belongs to the Sanitary Parc Taullí Corporation.

For the appraisal of the subjects of the study the following categories have been used: a) the punctuation among 30 and 33 suggests a light autistic disorder; b) the punctuation among 33, 5 and 36 suggests a moderate autistic disorder; and c) from punctuation 36, 5 it suggests a severe autistic disorder.

2.3 Design of the study

It is defined a duration of 6 months of treatment and 6 visits grouped in two phases - with the only goal to facilitate the elaboration of the information - are carried out. n the cases in which the subject is following a treatment prescribed by the neurologist or another specialist, this treatment is respected without introducing any modification.

PHASE A

It consists in two visits and all patients follow the same model of treatment that has been designed.

1st VISIT; Time 1

It consists in two parts:

First part of psychological type: the questionnaire DSM IV is passed in order to verify the diagnosis of the Disorder of the Autism Spectrum and an evaluation of the symptoms of autism according to the CARS test is carried out.

Second part of medical type: the clinical story of the patient is made and the organic acids and the morphopeptides of gluten and casein in urine are asked in the Laboratory Great Plains. Prescription: drainage for 6 weeks; from the 5th week DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) is introduced.

2nd VISIT

According to the results of the analyses of urine, the patients with a high concentration of gluten started a diet without gluten, those with a high concentration of casein peptides started a diet without milk nor did derivatives and those with a high both values start a diet without gluten nor milk nor derivatives. Into the same time digestive enzymes are introduced and intestinal flora. The ones that had high levels of arabinose, after a week of eliminating the sugar from the diet, started the antiparasitic treatment, introduced the intestinal flora and continued with the drainage until the antiparasitic treatment is finished. In this group the digestive enzymes are not introduced until the 3rd visit.

PHASE B

It consists in four visits and the introduction of the different supplements and homeopioids medicines; it’s made depending on the individual answer of each patient.

3rd, 4th, 5th VISIT

They keep on working in gradually and depending on the individual answer of each patient: a multivitamin, a supplement of calcium and magnesium, oligoelements, ornitine and tryptophan and TMG (trimethylglycine) in presentation of magisterial formula, treatment of homeospagyria, and dopamine and homeopathic serotonin.

6th VISIT; Time 2

The CARS questionnaire is passed for the second time and the same analyses of urine are asked again in the Laboratory Great Plains.

2.4 Collecting information

In the first visit the following information is collected:

„ Family antecedents of disorders in behaviour, intestinal

disorders, alimentary allergies, infections as candid,

fibromiàlgies...

„ Personal Story: pregnancy, delivery, lactation, reactions to

vaccines, hospital admissions, other symptoms or

concomitant illnesses, intestinal habit, allergies...

„ Evolution of the autism: behaviour during the first months of

life, first signals of alert, existence of regression in the

behaviour....

A table, for each one of the subjects of the sample, is elaborated with the items of the CARS, that had resulted altered and, in each visit, a copy is given to the families for every week until the next visit. They are asked them to note down all changes that are produced from the former visit, as well as any possible observation with respect to other symptoms of behaviour, physicists, or other modifications in the usual medication of the subject.

2.5 Treatments and posologies

Table 1.- Relation between medicines and supplements

HOMEOSPAGYRIA + 6 years old – 1pill. 3/day

6-11years old – 4 drops 3/day

+ 12years old – 5drops 3/day

6-11years old- 4 drops 3/day +12years old- 5 drops3/day

Marbisan 3-5years old – 3drops 3/day 6-11years old – 4drops 3/day

+ 12years old – 5drops 3/day

DHA Algatrium 50mg/kg/day
ENZIMS DIGESTIUS Seren Aid 2 capsules 2/day(midday and
night, before dinner)
Treatment Antiparasitic Black Walnut Following the treatment guides
Of Dr. Hulda Clark Clove of Dr.Clark according to age.
Artemisia Absinthe
Wormwood
Ornitine
FLORA INTESTINAL Symbiolact 1 sachet /day
(Rhamnosus)*
MULTIVITAMÍNIC SuperNuthera 3 ml/morning
SUPLEMENT de Ca, Mg. InmunoComplex 1 capsule/day
OLIGOELEMENTS Ifigen; Si, Zn, Mg 5 ml./night
Ifigen; Si, Zn, Mg, B, 5 ml./morning
Mn, Cr
FORMULA MAGISTRAL TMG 175 mg, Ac. 2 capsules/morning
Folinic 200 mg, Vit. 2 capsules/night

B12 6 mg,

Tryptophan 150 mg

3 mg, Vit B3 5 mg, Vit B6 6 mg, Vit B12 6 mg.

HOMEOSPAGYRIA Lidospag 3-5years old – 3drops 2/day 6-11years old – 4 drops 2/day

+
12years old – 5drops 2/day
6-11years old – 4 drops 2/day
+
12years old – 5drops 2/day
6-11years old – 4 drops 2/day
+
12years old – 5drops 2/day
+
6 years old -1 pills 2/day

Sulkasar 3-5 years old – ½ pills 2/day

+ 6 years old -1 pills 2/day

HOMEOPATIA Serotoninum 2 granuls/nit Muriatium 5 CH

Dopamine 5 CH 2 granuls/matí

* It has only been administrated to one subject that showed high values of HPHPA (acid 3-(3hidroxifenil)-3 hidroxypropionic) in urine, indicate the presence of clostridia.

3 RESULTS

3.1 Description of the sample

3.1 Description of the sample

We’ve selected 20 subjects that had already made the first visit and the initial analyses.

The distribution by sexes it’s been: 16 men and 4 women.

Two of them are schooled in ordinary school with support, and 18 in school with special education. The subjects came from 9 different special education schools and 2 from ordinary schools.

From the second visit, we had 7 that left because of the following reasons:

  • 4 of them because of family issues: familiar problems, difficulties following the diet and treatments,…
  • 2 subjects experimented an increase in nervous and aggressively during the drainage.
  • 1 subject after improving with the drainage and the antifungal treatment feels more nervous and unquiet when starting to take vitamins and other supplements.

Due to the interest that has for itself the entire datum concerning the set of the initial sample of the 20 subjects, it has been kept all the aspects of the clinical history the information regarding the 20 subjects and its called initial sample. The 13 subjects group that followed the treatment until the end it is called effective sample. So, from now on the initial sample will be the group of 20 subjects that made the first visit and whom we have results of the first analysis and the effective sample are the 13 subjects that followed the treatment until the end and whom we have also the second analysis and the second evaluation of the CARS test.

3.1.1 Distribution of the second sample according to sex and age

The distribution according to age it is collected in the next table.

Table 2.- Distribution of the initial sample and the effective according to the subject’s age

AGE (years) 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 T.
Initial sample 1 1 0 3 1 2 4 3 1 2 2 20
Effective sample 1 1 0 3 0 1 3 1 1 0 2 13

The distribution by sexes is i son the initial sample: 16 of masculine sex and 4 of feminine sex in the effective sample: 10 of masculine sex and 3 of the feminine sex.

3.1.2 Other associated pathologies

Table 3.- Relation of associated pathologies in the initial and effective sample

Pathology Initial sample (cases) Effective sample (cases)
Epilepsy subclinical 3 2
Down's Syndrome 1 1
Panhypopituitarism 1 1
Dysfunction of the suprarenal glandules 1 1
Malformation renal asymptomatic and betathalassemia 1 1

3.1.3 Family antecedents

In 7 of 20 cases we’ve considered the existence of familiar antecedents that could be relevant.

Table 4.- Relation of familiar antecedents of the initial an effective sample

Familiar antecedents Initial sample (cases) Effective sample (cases)
Fibromyalgia (*) 3 3
TEA (**)(Disorders of the Autism Spectrum) 3 2
Brothers with worse pathologies(***) 2 2
Parkinson: grandfather 1 1
Down's Syndrome: father's aunt 1 1
2 abortions before of the mother 1 1
Mother chronic vaginal Candidiasis 1 1

(*) In one case the aunt, in other case the grandmother and in other the aunt and the grandmother. (**) One case the mother’s cousin, one case the uncle and one case the grandfather. (***) One case of congenital cardiopathy and one case of death after 48h of being born.

3.1.4 Personal antecedents

PREGNANCY

We’ve registered the following incidents regarding the pregnancy that affected 10 cases of all 20.

Table 5.- Relation of incidents during the pregnancy

Incidence Initial sample (cases) Effective sample (cases)
FIV (fecundation in vitro) 1 0
Donors embryos 1 1
Very stressful fright 1 1
Stress, depression and hard flu + antibiotic therapy 1 1
Urinary infection + antibiotic therapy and vaginal pruritus during pregnancy 1 1
Pielonephritis + antibiotic therapy 8th month 1 0
Metrorrhagia and rest on the 1st, 2nd and 3rd trimesters 1 1
Albuminuria 6th month 1 1
Fainting with conscience lost at 8th month 1 1
Diabetes Mellitus in pregnancy 1 1

PART In 15 of 20 cases there’s been one of the following incidences

Table 6.- Relation of incidents during the delivery

Incidence Initial sample cases Effective sample cases
Caesarea 7 3
Distocic birth 5 4
Birth induction 4 3
Foetal suffering 2 1
Preterm at 7 months 1 1

Neonatal infection

1

REACTION TO THE VACCINES In 7 of 20 cases there was some kind of post vaccines reaction. The vaccines used were:

Table 7.- Relation of reactions to the vaccines in the initial and effective sample

Vaccine Initial sample cases Effective sample cases
Triple Viral 4 3
DTP Polio (diphtheria tetanus poliomyelitis) 2 1
Prevenar 1 1

The reactions that happened were:

  • Edema of inferior limb (no local edema). Effective sample
  • Fever + hypoglycaemia. Effective sample
  • Adenophlegmon laterocervical with surgical drainage. Effective sample
  • Edema local + fever + otitis. Effective sample
  • Fever + vomit. Initial sample
  • Regresion of development and increase of the autism symptoms. Initial sample.

REGRETIONS IN BEHAVIOUR

In 9 cases of 20 it was produced a regression on the behaviours in the development of the child, as it is collected by ages in the following table.

Table 8.- Relation of regressions of the behaviour in the initial and effective sample

Age Initial sample (cases) Effective sample (cases)
13 months 1 1
15 months 2 1
18 months 2 2
24 months 3 1
30 months 1 1

3.2 Results of the first urine analysis. Time 1

3.2.1 Initial sample

The results of the analysis of 20 subjects that started the study are represented in the table and following scheme.

Graphic 2.- Description of the initial sample according to the results obtained in arabinose, gluteomorphine and caseomorphine -20 subjects-

Arabinose

Table 9.- Description of the initial sample according to the results obtained in arabinose, gluteomorphine and caseomorphine.

Variable Total Gluteomorphine Caseomorphine Arabinose All three
Gluteomorphine (gluten) 4 0 0 1 3
Caseomorphine (milk) 15 0 3 9 3
Arabinose 16 1 9 3 3

One subject scored negative in all three parameters. Three subjects scored positive in all three parameters.

3.2.2 Effective sample

The results of the 13 subjects that finished the study are present in the following scheme and table:

Graphic 3.- Description of the effective sample according to the results obtained in arabinose, gluteomorphine and case morphine -13 subjects-Time 1

Arabinose

Table 10.- Description of the effective sample according to the results obtained in arabinose, gluteomorphine and case morphine. Time 1

Variable Total Gluteomorphin e Caseomorphin e Arabinosa All three
Gluteomorphine(glut en)